Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Kelsey Shay

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

State Farm® Insurance Agent

Kelsey Shay

(904) 849-1988
86058 St Peter Blvd
Yulee, FL 32097

Lofton Creek

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Kelsey Shay

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
9am - 4pm
Call us 24 hours a day!


86058 St Peter Blvd
Yulee, FL 32097



I am proud to be a State Farm Agent serving the people of North Florida. My past experience has allowed me the opportunity to see State Farm make a difference in the lives of our customers. I am passionate about helping families plan for their futures be there when the unexpected occurs. I enjoy spending time with my family and being involved in the community.

Yulee Insurance, Fernandina Insurance, Jacksonville insurance, North Jacksonville Insurance, Nassau County Insurance, Quote car insurance, Quote homeowners insurance, Quote renters insurance, Quote life insurance Quote health insurance, online banking, Relocation Quotes, First Time Home Buyer

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products


Start out strong with 4 financial priorities for young adults

Debt and little savings can stand in the way of financial success. Read about financial priorities so you can start out strong.

The Real Consequences of Drunk Driving

What's at stake if you're caught drunk driving? A lot. These tips help you avoid the dangers of drinking and driving.

The importance of safety glasses and when to wear them

Learn about the importance of wearing eye protection, the different types and features that can help increase your safety and prevent eye injury.

View More Articles

We are here to build relationships with the people in our Nassau County Community and be your local good neighbor! We help navigate customers through their insurance needs and providing a plan for you and your family. Our insurance professionals are trained to assist customers in reaching their personal financial goals while protecting what's most important. We are dedicated to providing the highest level of customer service while meeting our customers needs and making insurance fun!

I proudly serve North Florida as a State Farm agent. My State Farm office is located in beautiful Yulee, FL and offers Auto, Homeowners, Renters, Business, Life & Health and Pet Insurance, as well as other policy services.

We primarily serve the areas of Yulee, Fernandina, Callahan, Hilliard, Bryceville and North Jacksonville and everywhere else in Nassau County, but my office is licensed to help all of Florida and Georgia with their insurance needs!

I’m a second-generation State Farmer and am originally from Bloomington, IL, where State Farm’s Headquarters is. I originally began my State Farm career in 2011 with our Catastrophe Claims Team in Jacksonville, FL. I eventually worked my way up into leadership within our Customer Care Center before becoming an agent in 2018.

I was inspired to become a State Farm agent so I could have more of an impact at the local level. My professional staff and I genuinely love what we do and prioritize having needs-based conversations with our customers so they can put the right coverage in place for the families and assets.

I also enjoy serving my community by volunteering at local events and helping our local food bank. I hold a bachelor’s degree in Business Management from the University of Missouri and my Charter Property Casualty Underwriter designation.

When I have free time, I like spending time with my family at the beach, sporting events and concerts.

Stop by my State Farm office or give us a call today for a free, no-obligation insurance quote!

Marissa McDonald State Farm Agent Team Member

Marissa McDonald

Account Representative

Growing up in a large family of six and playing competitive sports I learned the importance of a team. Through my experience in customer service, I have had the opportunity to interact with a variety of people and strive to always try to establish a connection to make sure I am meeting customer expectations. My dedication to our State Farm customers and being apart of a strong team at Kelsey Shay's allows me to premier service while meeting our State Farm customers needs.

Taylor Christmas State Farm Agent Team Member

Taylor Christmas

Account Representative

I am a local born and raised right here in Nassau County! I enjoy spending time with my family and riding my horses when I have some down time! I have 8 years of experience in the insurance industry where I am passionate about helping families understand their insurance needs! I look forward to meeting you here in our office, swing by for coffee!
Fannie Eisenman State Farm Agent Team Member

Fannie Eisenman

Account Representative

Fannie joins us from Kentucky and has found her forever home here in Nassau County! Fannie started in the insurance industry in 2022 and has enjoyed being a part of our Sales Team, helping people with the auto, home and life insurance needs. When she is not at work she enjoys cruises, concerts and anything near the water!
Lindsay Kelley State Farm Agent Team Member

Lindsay Kelley

Customer Service Representative

Lindsay is a small-town girl from Lake City, FL, and recently moved to Nassau County with her husband and wonderful little girl. Lindsay enjoys working together with her team and strives to provides remarkable customer service! She enjoys being a part of our community and the Kelsey Shay State Farm team!
Haley Tipton State Farm Agent Team Member

Haley Tipton

Customer Service Representative

Born and raised in Maryland, I moved to the Sunshine State in 2020. I have chosen to plant my roots firmly in Nassau County while providing and servicing the insurance needs of my fellow neighbors. I enjoy educating our insureds on the numerous ways we can help protect what is important most to them.
Reiss Holt State Farm Agent Team Member

Reiss Holt

Account Representative

I'm Reiss Holt, your dedicated Account Representative with 5+ years of insurance experience. I help customers find products that meet their insurance needs and licensed to do so in Florida. My goal is to guide you through a comprehensive process that brings you peach of mind. Outside of work, i enjoy golfing, attending sports events, exploring new places, and spending time with loved ones. Contact our office for a quote on auto, home, life and health insurance! Your satisfaction is our priority!

Our Agency

  • Our mission is to help people manage the risks of everyday life, recover from the unexpected and realize their dreams.
  • We help customers with their insurance and financial services needs, including Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Life Insurance, Business Insurance, College Planning, Health Insurance, and Renters Insurance.
  • Our office is located in Yulee, FL.
  • Our office is open Mon-Thurs 8:30am-5:30pm; Fri 8:30am-5:00pm; Sat10:00am-2:00pm.
  • I am a proud graduate of University of Missouri.

We are a growing agency with big dreams and lots of potential. If you're willing to work hard and you expect to get results from yourself and those around you, we want to meet you and talk about the opportunity we have for you. If you are self-motivated, possess an entrepreneurial spirit and have a desire to win and achieve results, please consider joining our team.

Learn more about our agency and the career opportunities with us.
Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.